Earlier  
Later
New Search
Posted Nick Remark
#openstack-nova - 2026-03-30
16:16:12 Uggla tkajinam, thanks for your answer on the ML for AMD-SNP.
16:16:43 tkajinam Uggla, np
16:17:30 Uggla Do you think you can have a draft spec to discuss at PTG ? And then give the hand for refinement and implementation to someone else ?
16:17:50 tkajinam yeah I can
16:17:59 tkajinam I also had a chat with some folks from LY regarding sev-snp and they told me that they already created their own implementation.
16:18:29 tkajinam I guess they are also preparing spec in their side. I'll check it with them in case they are ready to submit their version
16:18:41 Uggla super cool, thanks. And interesting to know that people for LY corp already have something.
16:18:56 Uggla Any chance to have a joined spec ?
16:18:59 tkajinam masahito, just fyi ^^^
16:19:07 tkajinam yeah I think that's better
16:20:33 gibi just to my limited brain capacity, so this means tkajinam will help with the spec (joint or not) but we need somebody who takes over and implements it
16:20:41 gibi is it a correct understanding?
16:20:53 Uggla gibi, yes
16:20:56 gibi OK
16:21:25 Uggla Anton will work on the TDX implementation though.
16:22:25 gibi I feel that even with the refactoring we have a chance that the TDX and the SNP work will merge conflict, do we have some mitigation planned, or we just use the first come first server rule?
16:22:47 Uggla Noob question regarding HW, what is supporting AMD-SNP ? Special AMD CPUs ?
16:22:57 sean-k-mooney on the topic of the PTG we likely need to schdule a cyborg cross project session but i have not formulated a specific adgenda yet.
16:23:04 tkajinam Technically I can provide a draft code but I may not have enough time to set up test environment for it. (due to my focus shifting away from these confidential computing things atm)
16:23:15 sean-k-mooney Uggla: not specificly specil but ranter a specific genreation
16:23:16 tkajinam Uggla, yeah you need specific generation of EPYC processor which supports SEV-SNP
16:23:34 sean-k-mooney as in i think you need 3rd generation EPYC or later
16:23:41 tkajinam and relatively new kernel + qemu + libvirt, which actually supports host features to use SEV-SNP
16:23:42 tkajinam yeah
16:24:15 sean-k-mooney i woudl need to check but i think we have access interenaly to at least 1 AMD host that supprot SNP
16:24:16 Uggla ok gonna check what is required in term of HW, to know if we have host supporting it.
16:25:06 tkajinam gibi, I agree these two can cause conflict but I guess the conflict can be easily resolved because we don't expect object change.
16:25:13 Uggla gibi, regarding the merge conflic, I expect a lot from the refactoring to limit them.
16:25:23 gibi OK
16:25:41 Uggla but we will see.
16:26:33 Uggla I think we are done with that topic.
16:27:25 Uggla And yes sean-k-mooney, we can work together to have a cross session with cyborg.
16:28:11 Uggla FYI, I will be on PTO next week, but back 1 week before PTG to prepare it.
16:28:37 Uggla ok moving on to next topic
16:28:45 Uggla #topic Stable Branches
16:28:59 elodilles thx
16:29:11 elodilles actually the situation is the same as last week
16:29:17 elodilles #info nova stable gates should be OK
16:29:23 elodilles #info placement and osc-placement have blocked stable gates, fixes need stable cores review (see: https://review.opendev.org/q/topic:pin-setuptools-81-docs and https://review.opendev.org/q/topic:pin-setuptools-81-via-virtualenv-pkg-resources )
16:29:38 elodilles i'd appreciate stable core reviews on these ^^^
16:29:46 elodilles #info stable branch status / gate failures tracking etherpad: https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/nova-stable-branch-ci
16:29:58 elodilles details are here ^^^
16:30:08 elodilles and that's all from me
16:30:45 Uggla thx elodilles maybe I will have a look but can't +2.
16:31:35 Uggla #topic vmwareapi 3rd-party CI efforts Highlights
16:31:45 Uggla fwiesel, something from your side ?
16:31:48 sean-k-mooney if we are ok wiht proxying elod i can +2w later if nowone else review but im reviing them now
16:32:01 Uggla sean-k-mooney thx
16:32:08 elodilles sean-k-mooney Uggla : thanks both of you o/
16:32:19 fwiesel Hi, I am digging into the issues with the hanging image upload.
16:32:33 fwiesel I hope, I have a solution: https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/oslo.vmware/+/982614 But I want to verify it first.
16:32:40 gibi fwiesel: thanks
16:33:00 gibi I will keep an eye on our WIP
16:33:06 fwiesel It takes more time, because a couple of other problems happened. (Such as expired certificates)
16:33:36 fwiesel I'll be on PTO on next Monday, so I can report back on the Monday after that
16:33:46 gibi fwiesel: OK, have a good PTO
16:33:58 fwiesel But I am optimistic, I can validate the fix this week.
16:34:04 fwiesel That's it from my side.
16:34:20 Uggla spoil, we might not have a meeting next week
16:35:07 Uggla thx fwiesel
16:35:13 Uggla #topic Gibi's news about eventlet removal
16:35:15 bauzas I'm all in for punting the meeting next week
16:35:51 gibi o/
16:36:04 gibi top of what we discussed in the gate section I have one additional new
16:36:05 gibi s
16:36:40 gibi I saw novncproxy working in native threading mode with sambork's patch. so good progress there
16:36:52 Uggla \o/
16:36:59 Uggla thx sambork
16:37:15 gibi I left a bunch of comments in the patch but we are moving in the right direction I belive
16:37:43 gibi that is all from me
16:37:56 Uggla thx gibi
16:38:14 Uggla #topic Nova using openstack sdk for neutron
16:38:34 Uggla layos is not anymore available, so pasting what he said earlier:
16:38:51 Uggla "from my side I worked/working on the patch for migrating security-groups to SDK, so some progress with it :-)"
16:39:20 sean-k-mooney oh not aviabel to attend the meeting not "not avaible to contineu the work"
16:40:04 Uggla ?
16:40:06 sean-k-mooney for a series like that we proably dont want this to be all or nothing. so it might be worth seeing fi we can land some of the eaierl patches. which that said i have not looked at it in at least a release
16:40:26 sean-k-mooney "layos is not anymore available,"
16:40:36 Uggla I mean for this meeting
16:40:39 sean-k-mooney ya
16:41:01 sean-k-mooney i tought you were annouching they would not have tiem to work on it this cycle. that was my misuderstandign
16:41:35 elodilles nope :) Lajos will continue to work on this but had to leave for the day ;)
16:41:52 Uggla sorry for the misunderstanding. Layos will continue working on the patches.
16:42:42 Uggla shame on me I have to look at these patches too, but I have not done it again.
16:43:21 Uggla ok next topic
16:43:28 Uggla #topic Bug scrubbing
16:43:37 Uggla #info up to 199 (stable)
16:43:57 Uggla #info I managed to keep it stable last week.
16:44:05 Uggla #link: https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/nova-bug-triage-roster
16:44:11 Uggla #link: https://truc.uggla.fr/ to follow the trend.
16:45:00 opendevreview Merged openstack/osc-placement stable/2024.2: [CI][stable-only] Workaround for missing pkg_resources https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/osc-placement/+/979691
16:45:29 Uggla I'am a bit late on the schedule, but I will try to schedule a bug squashing session wednesday around 16:30 UTC. I'will keep you posted on the ML.
16:46:29 Uggla So I'd like people who has bug in the rooster to join if they need to discuss about triaging a bug.
16:46:34 opendevreview Merged openstack/osc-placement stable/2025.1: [CI][stable-only] Fix docs job https://review.opendev.org/c/openstack/osc-placement/+/979692
16:47:39 Uggla that's all for this topic today, please look at the ML for further information.
16:48:00 Uggla #topic Open discussion
16:48:12 Uggla Uggla: Suggest no meeting next week. 6th April is a public holiday in most European countries.
16:48:33 Uggla I saw bauzas agree too earlier
16:48:40 Uggla Someone against that ?
16:48:42 gibi +1 from me too

Earlier   Later