Posted	Nick	Remark
#openstack-cyborg - 2019-04-03
03:17:13	Sundar_	One is at the Intel booth, with a real-world app (genomics) + CYborg + Nova in upstreamable form. Probably no programming here.
03:17:44	Li_Liu	is it on-site server or off-site server?
03:17:49	Sundar_	Other is for the Nova folks. There have been several asks, and I am trying to show programming. But we don;t have full discovery
03:17:56	yikun	so this one including the e2e device attach demo? :)
03:18:10	yikun	I mean the 1st one
03:18:34	Sundar_	Nova folks want to see discovery but we have to say the Intel OPAE driver is WIP. I have some setup scripts to populate the Cyborg db and Placemen directly
03:19:08	Sundar_	yikun: First one also does not have discovery
03:19:42	Li_Liu	demo is always hacky :P
03:19:46	Sundar_	Li_Liu: on-site server : I'll either do a live demo or use a some video for backup
03:20:18	Sundar_	Yes, a few hacks but, IMHO, Nova's real interest should be in Cyborg APIs and how they get called
03:20:39	Sundar_	Internals of device discovery shouldn;t matter -- except that Cyborg should not conflict with PCI whitelist
03:20:39	Li_Liu	I see
03:21:15	Sundar_	Li_Liu: my question is, is it too late to get a room for the demo?
03:21:23	Li_Liu	We can just pre-populate the DB as if the discovery is happening
03:21:39	Li_Liu	you mean during the PTG or summit?
03:21:54	Sundar_	PTG
03:21:58	yikun	Sundar_: agree, so the key is show cyborg api/client and the key interface of attachment.
03:22:41	Li_Liu	Do we need an extra room for thedemo?
03:22:58	Li_Liu	I thought each team should be getting a room and we can just use that
03:23:36	Sundar_	A room with a projector, which can potentially accommodate a large #people. ( I am thinking of the bw provider demo for Neutron at last PTG)
03:24:02	Sundar_	Li_Liu: Ok, does that room have a projector?
03:24:05	Li_Liu	Another option is to show it during our project update session during summit
03:24:18	Li_Liu	I will ask them
03:24:26	Sundar_	I think Nova folks will have tons of questions
03:24:44	Sundar_	Would be good to do this at the PTG, drive discussion and closure
03:25:04	yikun	Maybe you could send a mail to ML, and arrange it in the beginning cyborg meeting/(or nova-cyborg meeting)
03:25:11	Sundar_	Li_Liu: Thanks
03:25:23	zhipeng	Please please use your phone to record it
03:26:10	yikun	if the demo video is available, and we can also send it to ML, and let the tons of question comes before PTG. :)
03:26:15	Sundar_	yikun, all: Yes, we need to set a time in consultation with Nova. May be Thursday or Friday, since many folks will not be there on Sat -- including yours truly.
03:27:27	Sundar_	On a related note, I am thinking of setting a cross-project with Ironic, because (a) Ironic deployments are going up, (b) people want accelerators in bare metal, and (b) this may a path to host K8s + accelerators on Cyborg
03:27:39	Sundar_	That would also require setting a specific time
03:28:22	Sundar_	Request to all of you: please fill out https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/cyborg-ptg-train , so that we can estimate how much time each will take.
03:29:05	Sundar_	I'll stop here, and let you folks speak -- for a change :)
03:29:10	Li_Liu	sure will do
03:29:15	yikun	ok
03:29:53	yikun	Sundar_: Note that 4.5 ~ 4.7 is china Chingming festival (So, Friday Sat Sun is vacation in China)
03:30:08	Sundar_	I see
03:30:55	zhipeng	Sundar_ big +1 on Ironic thought
03:31:14	Sundar_	zhipeng: :)
03:31:24	zhipeng	I've tried to get this started a while ago (Julia was not convinced back then )
03:32:11	Sundar_	I spoke to Julia too a couple of times. I agree, it was a bit premature without getting Nova fully lined up
03:33:25	zhipeng	Keep up the great work !
03:33:39	Sundar_	Another big thing coming up -- Intel PAC N3000 https://www.anandtech.com/show/13958/intel-fpga-pac-n3000
03:34:24	Sundar_	I'd like to present it in tomorrow's Zoom call. This has *huge* interest from telcos, and also represents quite some changes for CYborg.
03:34:48	Li_Liu	great, looking forward to it
03:34:56	Sundar_	I tried to fold this into our device model, but the details kept changing
03:35:51	wangzhh	Great!
03:36:06	Coco_gao	Sounds good.
03:36:16	Coco_gao	What about the demo, do you need any help?
03:37:00	Coco_gao	I think the discovery part may be functional, but not the nova interaction part.
03:37:41	Coco_gao	Could you pls introduce you demo a little bit in tommorows meeting?
03:37:59	Sundar_	Coco_gao: Yes. I am about to make one more set of changes, including support for programming with v2 API. Please review the pilot branch patches after that!
03:38:56	Sundar_	Coco_gao: I need to merge the master with the feature branch, and then we can see what parts ork
03:39:44	Sundar_	Re. Intro the demo tomorrow, please give me some more time. Because only today I got permission to merge master onto the pilot.
03:40:17	Coco_gao	Thank you, take your time.
03:40:57	zhipeng	The glorious git rebase
03:42:16	Sundar_	I tried a rebase, and #infra folsk said no, I need to do a merge. I tried the merge and that failed, because I need permissions. Then I have to figure out how to get those permissions. Now that is done -- so onto the glorious merge :)
03:42:20	openstackgerrit	Merged openstack/python-cyborgclient master: fix service name in client https://review.openstack.org/649493
03:43:00	Coco_gao	aha, I see the gerrit information.
03:43:41	Sundar_	Any other topic on PTG preparation?
03:44:40	Sundar_	#topic AoB
03:45:59	Sundar_	Li_Liu, loking forward to the room info. All the best for the RC2 cut.
03:46:34	Li_Liu	I have sent the email to confirm
03:46:45	Li_Liu	Will let you know once they get back to me
03:46:51	Sundar_	Thanks, Li_Liu
03:47:24	Li_Liu	np
03:47:54	Sundar_	Great job on Stein, and thanks everybody! Good day (or good night). Enjoy the Chingming festival!
03:48:04	Sundar_	#endmeeting
03:48:07	openstack	Meeting ended Wed Apr 3 03:48:04 2019 UTC. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot . (v 0.1.4)
03:48:08	openstack	Minutes: http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/openstack_cyborg/2019/openstack_cyborg.2019-04-03-03.02.html
03:48:09	openstack	Minutes (text): http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/openstack_cyborg/2019/openstack_cyborg.2019-04-03-03.02.txt
03:48:10	openstack	Log: http://eavesdrop.openstack.org/meetings/openstack_cyborg/2019/openstack_cyborg.2019-04-03-03.02.log.html
03:48:26	wangzhh	Thx Sundar, Bye all.
03:48:41	Coco_gao	Thanks for all the efforts.
03:48:44	Coco_gao	Bye
03:49:25	Li_Liu	bye
#openstack-cyborg - 2019-04-04
05:55:42	ikuo_o	Hi there, I want to join cyborg PTG from Japan and preparing for it.
05:56:18	ikuo_o	Does anybody know when the cyborg PTG will start and end? from 2nd to 4th May, all days?
05:57:22	zhipeng	Hey welcome !
05:57:38	zhipeng	We should have a etherpad you could check out
05:58:13	zhipeng	ikuo_o can you introduce yourself a little bit ?
05:59:42	ikuo_o	ok, I am an engineer from NTT. We are researching on high performance server platform using accelerators like FPGAs.
06:00:46	ikuo_o	we tried to use cyborg to control intel FPGA last year, and showed demo at NTT R&D forum last November..
06:01:43	ikuo_o	we want to improve cyborg so that it become useful for network carriers.
06:02:29	zhipeng	Wow
06:03:42	ikuo_o	maybe Sundar-san knows us. our colleague saw him at Berlin summit.
06:04:06	ikuo_o	tetsuro_ is one of my colleague.
06:06:44	ikuo_o	is this the etherpad url? https://etherpad.openstack.org/p/cyborg-ptg-train
06:07:09	ikuo_o	i wrote my name at the attendance.
06:07:51	zhipeng	Ah yes
06:07:57	zhipeng	Just found it lol
06:08:33	zhipeng	So from the schedule it looks like should be whole days, but discussion could end earlier for sure
06:10:27	ikuo_o	I see. it depends on the number of the topics to be added later, right?
06:11:52	zhipeng	From past experience, yes
06:19:24	ikuo_o	Thanks. I should add some topics to the etherpad.
06:20:05	ikuo_o	eg. checking FPGA contents for integrity, collecting FPGA resource usage for error handling.
06:28:53	zhipeng	That'd be awesome :)
06:33:09	ikuo_o	we don't have the exact solutions now, but I'm glad if we can discuss the problem and the way to solve it using cyborg for next release, at the PTG!
06:35:42	zhipeng	No solution required as always :)

Earlier   Later